Tuesday, 20 March 2018

Dialogue On Evolution with APOSL and Pantai Baptist Church

My good friend Samuel Nesan called me a few months ago to ask if the APOSL science club would like to debate about evolution. I immediately said yes. We met for dinner and talked about it. I envisioned a chance to engage creationists and also to tell them about evolution.
IMG_20180320_200653_HDR.jpg
That botak head belongs to my friend.
However, when I approached the rest of the group, they were not too enthusiastic about it. They felt that by having a debate, they would be agreeing that there was something to debate about i.e. creationism had merit or there was still doubt about evolution.
In the end, it was left to Dr Kok Sen Wai to sort out the mechanics of the “debate” with Samuel and they both agreed to change it to a dialogue.

The creationists were represented by Mark (a young pastor) and Silas (a lay pastor). The APOSLs were Howe (a Christian who rejects creationism) and Sen Wai (an agnostic).
Silas opened the dialogue by stating that creationists are not science deniers but they disagree with Natural Selection. He gave examples of how small chihuahuas cannot reproduce great Danes. He touched on how the finches in the Galapagos all came from the finch family since they were all finches. He stated that mutation always resulted in bad offspring such as a two headed turtle and mutant flies with no wings, and he believes that there are no positive mutation. Dogs will reproduce dogs and cats will reproduce cats and never the other way around.

Read more: Dialogue On Evolution with APOSL and Pantai Baptist Church

Sunday, 24 December 2017

Wednesday, 19 October 2016

Talk by Teng Yu He on her Fossil Hunting Expeditions

"I found out that Peninsula Malaysia has a suture line that splits it (no volcanoes) and types of fossils found here." Terence Tan



Saturday, 7 May 2016

APOSL is 4 Years Old This Year

Yesterday, APOSL celebrated our 4th birthday. There are over nine hundred people in the Facebook group. I am grateful for the handful of members who drive the events and projects.


 APOSL has always been lucky to have speakers to give talks when we are bored of documentaries.
 
Tshen gave a talk on Alfred Wallace in Lake Gardens. 

Kok Boon, a theoretical physicist, talked about the future of nuclear power in Malaysia.

Terence opened his home for APOSL to have BBQ and social meet ups.

 Some of us went to watch The Force Awakens.

 We made three videos for Melawan Sains Palsu.

 I made memes of Pac Kun just for fun.

And we went for a treasure hunt in Tanjung Sepat to celebrate our birthday. We honoured Alan Turing. We made new friends from Iraq and Iran.

It has been a fun 4 years. Thanks to everyone who contributed big and small to keep APOSL going.

Saturday, 20 February 2016

Brown Eggs Vs White Eggs


Dengue and Zika: Irresponsible Claims From University



Recently, a senior lecturer from Universiti Teknologi Malaysia (UTM), Dr Harisun Yaakob, claimed to have found a cure for dengue and Zika. The supposed cure came in the form of herbal pills based on papaya leaves. The news was carried by many local newspapers and portals.

Such claims are very irresponsible and misleading. 


Luckily, the Health Department has countered the claims and produced a guide on what constitutes medicine and what constitutes 'claims'.

It goes on to state, "Semakan yang dibuat mendapati produk ‘Anti D’ngue’ tidak berdaftar dengan PBKD dan juga tidak ada kelulusan untuk produk tersebut digunakan dalam kajian ke atas manusia. ('Anti D'ngue' is not registered with the ministry and also has no approval for the product to be used in a study on humans.)

And, "Sehingga kini juga, belum ada produk dengan formulasi berasaskan herba yang didaftarkan oleh PBKD untuk merawat demam Denggi atau Zika." (To date, there has not been a product with herbal formulations registered by the minitry to treat dengue fever or Zika.)

Kenyataan Akhbar KPK 20 Feb 2016: Isu Kapsul dari Daun Betik, Minyak Kelapa Dara & Beberapa Herba Lain yang Dihasilkan oleh Pihak Universiti Teknologi Malaysia sebagai Anti-Denggi & Anti-Zika (http://kpkesihatan.com/2016/02/20/kenyataan-akhbar-kpk-20-feb-2016-isu-kapsul-dari-daun-betik-minyak-kelapa-dara-beberapa-herba-lain-yang-dihasilkan-oleh-pihak-universiti-teknologi-malaysia-sebagai-anti-denggi-anti-zika/)

Saturday, 9 January 2016

2014: Disagreement, censorship and shaming in APOSL


Yesterday, Afiq posted this and some APOSLs voiced their distaste:
https://www.facebook.com/groups/aposlmy/permalink/1002040719839473/?comment_id=1002330653143813&ref=notif&notif_t=group_comment_follow

APOSL will be 4 years old this year. I remember starting this club with the target of getting 100 members. Today there are over 900 members in our Facebook group!

Our goal is to propagate science and we have done as much as we could over the last four years. We have held monthly meetings, invited speakers to give talks, done street surveys, produced science videos, visited science museums, supported projects and connected with other science-based bodies.

There are two areas we do not touch: politics and religion. Both are touchy subjects. Both bring out the worst of people at times. Now, there is little connection between politics and science, however, I know APOSL will have to face religion and science sometime, sooner or later.

The comments on Afiq's post were interesting to me because a few APOSL members countered him with facts and evidence. I have met Afiq before and I am sure he is not a bigot nor xenophobic. I guess he could have framed his concerns better in his post but I get the gist of what he is trying to say. I must say, I have learned new things by his post and the responses posted.

I feel shaming and censorship should only be left as the last option, for the extreme, dog-headed, die-die-cannot-be-wrong, won't-change-his-mind, loud-mouth person.

Opinions by members are just opinions, they do not represent the club. We should respond to genuine concerns and questions. If we shame and censor people, who will ask any more questions or open new discussions? Instead, we should continue to respond in a civilised manner and be nice.

I do not think APOSL will accept posts that belittle religion (see example below) but we should open ourselves to genuine questions and concerns that may step in the area of religion

Not something to post on APSOL's FB group.



 APSOLs could respond to questions like:
  • Age of the Earth
  • Origin of the universe
  • Origin of life
  • Angels and demons 
2016, we can do it!

Saturday, 3 October 2015

Talk: Malaysia's Nuclear Age

This talk was given by Kok Boon Cheong, a theoretical physicist. He had done some research into nuclear power and came over to share his findings with us.

He thinks is a bad idea for Malaysia to go nuclear for several reasons:
  • The cost is very high. A generation 3 or generation 4 nuclear power plant will cost billions and given Malaysia's record of corruption (think PKFZ, KLIA2 etc), the final cost will probably be several times more.
  • The level of expertise needed is very high. Over 30 fields of expertise are needed to run a nuclear power plant efficiently. However, Boon is not confident that Malaysia can sustain a high level of professionalism to ensure the plant is run properly.
It seems Malaysia and Korea experimented with nuclear reactors in the 1980's but today, the Malaysia Nuclear Agency conceeds we are now 30 years behind Korea.

He suggested the country look into solar, wind, biomass and tidal energy.

Sunday, 23 August 2015

Melawan Sains Palsu Bloopers 22.8.15

To shoot 2 one-minute videos took us half a morning. We started at 7.30am with breakfast and finished at 10am. Here is the reason why.

Manusia Memakai 10% Otak Saja?

APOSL Melawan Sains Palsu. Script by Muhammad Musoddiq Bin Jaafar. Please share!

Apa Itu Deria Ke-6?

APOSL's Melawan Sains Palsu video shoot. Muhammad Musoddiq Bin Jaafar wrote the script. Shot at Penchala Terrace.

Sunday, 9 August 2015

A.R. Wallace: Exploratory Journeys in Melaka & Sarawak, and his Influences on Malaysian Natural History Study



This wonderful talk was given by  Lim Tze Tshen, a research assistant at University Malaya.

I fetched the speaker at 4.15pm and made our way to Lake Gardens. Kian Keong was already eaiting for us there.

Upon arrival, we ate and chit chatted while waiting for the rest to show up.

This is the first time we have held a talk in the open, without the use of a projector. Participants had to download the presentation and load it into their smart phones so they could follow the speaker as he presented.

The talk was very intersting. It was obvious Tshen is a fan of Wallace's work and life. The man discovered and catalogued many thousands of species of flora and fauna found in our home country. His study was so extensive and authoratative that several animals and regions were named after him! Yet, until the talk, I did not know much about Wallace.


Tshen only covered Wallace's explorations in Malacca and Sarawak, and did not touch on his research into the theory of natural selection. Part 2 of his talk will be held another day, probbaly next year as APOSL already has events every month till October.

PS. Tshen is giving the same talk at People's Merdeka Exhibition (https://www.facebook.com/events/1456072861364575/permalink/1457800061191855/)

Saturday, 4 July 2015

The Surprise at Hari Rosalind Franklin

This year, we celebrated our birthday by honouring Rosalind Franklin.

Lyana helped us get a room in Universiti Malaya. I arrived early with my kids and Doppo to set up.

Only 5 people showed up at the appointed time. Nonetheless, we settled down to watch a documentary about Rosalind Franklin and the race to figure out the structure of the DNA while tucking into the food.

Most of the members were about an hour late!

I had organised a surprise for APOSL that day. It was a video of Rosalind Franklin's Student Council President saying hi to the science club! I had written to RFU a few weeks in advance. I did not think anything would come of it. To my relief, Maggie from RFU helped by asking Gabe to do the video. You can see the reaction of the APOSL members below.


After that, we sang happy birthday and had the most fabulous chocolate ganache cake made by Su.

Tuesday, 23 June 2015

Su's APOSL Visit To UM Zoology Museum: I make a lousy fossil

http://snuze.blogspot.com/2015/06/i-make-lousy-fossil.html

Some people want to become diamonds after they die. Some people want to be star dust again. Me, I'm happy to be fertiliser. Unless I could become a fossil, because that would be extremely cool. But then again, that isn't very likely.
I got an opportunity to see fossils first hand at the Universiti Malaya Museum of Zoology with the crew from the Advocates of the Propagation of Science Literacy (APOSL) on Saturday, April 25th. Whodathunkit there's a museum of natural history in the heart of the great metropolitan of Kuala Lumpur? 

Ta-da!

The Museum of Zoology is located in a new-ish block in the Institute of Biological Science (better known as ISB , Institut Sains Biologi), Faculty of Science. It is adjacent to the Institute of Mathematical Science (whose notice boards feature the most interesting stuff about numbers that even those allergic to maths like me find fascinating) and is open during weekdays from 9 am to 4 pm.


The entrance to the museum.

We were fortunate that the curator, Prof. Sasekumar, very graciously agreed to open the museum to us on a weekend and made himself available to show us around and answer our questions.

Prof. Sasekumar, the Curator.

He explained that a large number of the specimens were collected over the years from various sources. Some were donated by state museums that have run out of space to store their natural history specimens, while others were the university's own research collection. A few others were gifts from visiting biologists who brought specimens of animals that are common in their country, like the muskrat specimen from North America and a piranha from Brazil. It was here that I discovered that piranhas look a lot like pomfrets with bad teeth.

Prof. Sasekumar explaining the Earth's biological time scale.
Prof. Sasekumar began the tour by explaining the wonderful mural of the Earth's geological and biological time scale that was painstakingly done by students of the ISB. No members of the Homo spp. family were included in the mural as the most recent animal in the mural still predated Lucy by a few million years
 The Earth's biological time scale mural

 The Earth's geological time scale mural
The Curator further explained about how fossil evidence supports the biological time scale. He invited us to read further on the geological time scale as it was not his area of expertise and suggested that we speak to the Geology Department for more information.
One of the members asked Prof. Sasekumar if he has had to answer questions from students who are inclined towards creationism. His adroit answer was, "Let's keep science and religion separate." 


 Some of the resources available at the museum. Sticky tape is optional.

 Look at the date of the periodical at the far right. 

Prof. Sasekumar took us into his office for fossil viewing. I was gaping so much at this huge replica of a crinoid leaf fossil that I forgot to snap a pic. It looked like Han Solo in carbonite! He explained to us that fossils are generally expensive and that most that are on display are replicas of some sort. However, he did show us one of the few real fossil specimen of the museum which was a trilobite fossil. It was a lot smaller than what was shown in my biology text books, that's for sure.

Previously, there was no real effort to hunt for fossils in Malaysia. The recent discovery in Pahang gives hope to paleontologists and dinosaur hunters in the country for more exciting discoveries to come. The BBC has an excellent page of resources on fossils, which you can visit here.

 The Godfathers of Biology: Darwin, Linnaeus, Wallace and Mandel

Decorating the entrance to the exhibit are posters of the Godfathers of Biology; Charles Darwin, Carolus Linnaeus, Alfred Russel Wallace and Fr. Gregor Mandel. I can't wait for the September talk on Russell Wallace! Please visit the APOSL Facebook page for updates on this talk and other exciting events.

The Zoology Museum is divided into several sections: the Fossilarium (in Prof. Sasekumar's office), the Osteological exhibits, the Rainforest Diorama, the Animal Diversity exhibit, the River Basin Diorama and the Entomology Box.

The Osteological or bones exhibit feature several specimens that help us compare how form matches function in terms of skeletal structure. Although all bones are hardened by calcium, the structure differs to match the form and function of the animal.

Prey vs Predator skull comparison.

The crocodile skull above is an excellent example. Its skull is heavy, with a hinged jaw that gives it one of the most powerful bite in the animal kingdom. The muscles that hold the jaw open, however, are relatively weak, which makes the slamming force of the upper jaw snapping shut perfect for quick kills.

Their triangular teeth is perfect for tearing their  prey's flesh, but the lack of molars means that crocs cannot chew their food. Therefore, crocodiles use biting and whiplash motions to rip their prey apart and swallow the pieces whole. Think of it as swallowing your KFC drumstick as a whole piece. Plant-based food requires a lot of chewing to render it digestible, so this lack of molar also means a strict Atkins diet and no carbs for the crocs.

The crocodiles' metabolism is relatively sluggish and they take a long time to digest the pieces of prey that they swallowed. This is why they only need to eat every few weeks or so and spend most of their time just hanging out and chilling. Eyes at the top of their head are perfect for scouting careless prey moseying by where they lie in wait, half submerged.

Multi-teeth nightmares are made of these.

You expect to be frightened by the fangs of predators but nothing prepared me for the squirm-inducing teeth of herbivorous critters. Apparently plant-devouring critters have TONNES OF MOLARS to help them grind down their tough and fibrous vegetarian meals. I can't really explain why they give me the heebie-jeebies, but if you have trypophobia, you would probably understand.

Not serpent wine

No El Nino this year, thank God
I found the water cycle diorama interesting as it gave a good explanation about the great flood that affected Kelantan late last year. Did people really think that they can raze forests to a nub and that nature will not retaliate? Idiots.
Flood oracle

Scary tales.
We never really pay attention to soil loss because we are in the tropics. But in places where desertification is a problem, people scrutinise water movement and soil erosion in order to arrest the widening of deserts. Let's hope that we don't let things get that far before we do something concrete about our top soil loss.

The exhibit included some fine examples of the local fauna. Sadly, a number of them are already no more, and many more are on the endangered species list (e.g. kancil, binturong, tenggiling etc.). I'm an omnivor myself, but I don't get people who eat animals that are already diminished in number unless they actually dwell in the forest and cannot get poultry et al. What's wrong with sticking to beef, rabbits, chicken, etc? Assholes.
Tropical jungle animals

Corals and peat swamp forest
More on peat swamp forest.

I'm sure that not many of us here in Malaysia realise that we are home to more than one kind of swamp forest: the mangrove as well as peat swamp. Sepang used to be a humongous peat swamp forest reserve, as well as many areas dotting the coastline of the peninsula.
The mangroves are important because it provides a nursery for the natural fishery lots. Not to mention it helps to control coastal erosion, provides home to tonnes of biodiversity, help to detoxify the coastline and is a pretty neat place to visit.

Peat swamps are important because they are invaluable water catchment areas, provide shelter and food to migratory birds, enriches the soil, increases the underground water table reservoir, and many more. Sadly, they are also located in areas that are prime for development. I guess we'll only pay attention to the damage caused by loss of peat swamp forest when we have problems like flash floods and top soil loss.
Oh wait. It's already on going but nobody cares.

 Prof. Sasekumar explaining the difference between the stingless 
and regular bees


We ended the tour with a visit to the stingless bee colony housed outside the museum. The bees were acquired from an apiary in Melaka. They produce small quantities of high quality honey that the Institute sells on a seasonal basis. What a pity that our visit did not coincide with the season. *pouts*

 Stingless bee colony
The museum may be modest in size but is chock-full of information on Malaysia's environmental heritage with  its exhibits of preserved animal specimens and informative posters. The museum is happy to entertain tours of pax up to 20 people, so please contact them if you are interested!

Saturday, 20 June 2015

Melawan Sains Palsu Dalam Masyarakat



Hari ini APOSL menjemput Muhammad Musoddiq Bin Jaafar untuk memberi ceramah bertajuk Melawan Sains Palsu Dalam Masyarakat.

Beberapa bulan yang lalu, saya menjumpai satu komuniti Facebook bernama Pseudoscience Watch yang banyak membongkar produk-produk dan perkongsian online yang berasaskan sains yang tidak betul atau palsu. Saya mengajak kumpulan ini untuk berkongsi pandangan mereka dengan APOSL.

Mereka menghalakan saya kepada Muhammad Musoddiq. Muhammad memegang ijazah dari Universiti Malaya dalam bidang Eksperimen Fizik.

Pada mulanya beliau berkata dia akan bercakap selama 30 minit sahaja disebapkan bulan puasa. Tetapi akhirnya, dia bercakap selama 2 jam!

Dia menjelaskan ilmu yang digunakan oleh orang-orang tertentu dan syarikat-syarikat tertentu yang mempromosikan produk-produk yang meragui. Satu daripadanya ialah produk yang boleh detox badan daripada racun-racun dalaman, kononnya. Produk ini dilekatkan pada tapak kaki dan kaki direndam dalam air. Setelah beberapa minit, air kelihatan gelap. Kononnya itu adalah racun yang keluar daripada badan pesakit dengan pertolongan produk yang berkenaan. Kami para hadirin semua gelak apabila ketahui fakta yang sebenar daripada Muhammad.

Selepas perkongsian Muhammad, kami bercadang untuk menghasilkan video pendek untuk orang awam supaya tidak tertipu oleh produk-produk yang mempunyai dakwaan yang luar biasa.